Forgot your password?
Not a member yet? Join us!
This is how you'll be known on the site. Choose wisely - it can't be changed.
Make it 3 characters or more, and type it twice to be sure.
We won't spam you or sell your address, but we might need to keep in touch about your account.
By clicking "Join Threadless!", you agree to our Terms of
Service and Privacy
The Design shows a bread jumping happily out of a toaster, with a new tan.
I like the pastel colors but maybe make the toast darker, and well, toastier. Also make it look more like he is in motion. I really like the concept just add some darkness and motion attributes, check out mine? http://www.threadless.com/critique/99508/RainbowTie
I like the idea of it. I agree with the above. Maybe make him a little darker, and maybe show some "untoasted" bread sort of laying casual on the side, waiting? Cute though.
Mine? link text
Hey thanks for the feedback you gave me on my design.
On yours, i suggest you redo the depth lines on the toaster lever and slots - they don't seem to be on the right line with each other. I like the isometric view but i think you have a few small perspective issues.
Other than that, it's a fun concept it just needs a little tweaking :)
Love it! Wouldn't change a thing. Strike that... I might create more of a contrast with the bread crust. Maybe some sesame seeds or something of that nature. Really that's just nitpicking so I'd submit this for sure. Good luck and thanks for your critique!
yay!!!! maybe he should have a tan!!!! (or a tan line)
I Have a design up for voting, please check it out! It's Zelda Inspired! Don't mess with the chickens
i agree with the others, more of a tan and maybe an untanned one waiting in line for contrast to get the concept across. very cute though, i like it!
I like it as it is. Love the colors. But is the bread guys right arm attached at it's back?
I agree with the others also on the most part. Definitely fix the arm. You could fix the toaster slots, but not necessarily the lever. It sort of looks cool being a little off like that. It is a cartoon after all. Really nicely done apart from those minor points. I like the look on the toast's face. :)
I'd have to agree about making the toast a bit darker. and maybe the t-shirt a shade lighter? Really nice concept though! With a little work I'm sure I'll get through.,
I think the top right corner of the toaster is too pointy, and it distracts from the main subject, make it more curved.
Maybe make the eye lines of the bread thicker? they seem too thin compared to the line weight of the rest.
Also try adding some texture to the bread, like little dots.
Looks great! Perhaps add a little color to the toast and a little shine to the toaster.
Comment on my toast themed design if you'd like!
Ya I love it, only I think the bread could use a bit more color if thats what you were going for, he looks a little pale currently, but overall great idea. If you'd like to look at mine
i agree about the tan lines and another piece of bread waiting--i really like it!
Thanks for commenting my design! I think you should add some toasty like marks to the bread but other than that it's great!
Hi: Based on your comments, I have worked on my design and made some changes, which are: Added speed and motion lines, added sesame seeds, fixed left arm, worked on toaster leaver and made bread darker with a more contrasting tan line around the face.
Please let me know your opinion on these changes and on the design to see if it is going on the right direction. All comments are welcome and appretiated.
this is looking good.. i think its ready...
if you have time please comment on mine..
Add some highlights.
I love your idea.
I'd say this is good to go. You've fixed up the points people suggested quite well.
I still think that face is real funny too. :)
Like the first version best (But with the arm fix... simple and clean
Cute! The only thing I might add is a couple of white lines at an angle (//) on the toaster to add some shine
I'm liking this version a lot. Saxy might be onto something with the shine, but I think it looks really good as it is, and that might be doing too much. Sweet desigh man.
Arges with above.
Super cute! i think it's good to go :)
Love it! very cute, and I think it looks ready.
Some grain or dots on the face of the bread would make it look better imo, coming along nice!.
i like the simplicity, it's nicely done. i think it's ready!
I like this a lot more! Nice definition on the crust and darker colors make it wonderful!
Funny concept. I don't think the tiny motion lines are necessary. They disrupt the clean simplicity of the overall design. The shirt placement is quite large. It may read as more comical were it less "in your face". Lastly, because the design is so simple and clean, little differences become noticeable; such as the eyes being different shapes and not centered over the mouth. I would tighten things up a little before final submission.
Oh man.... I really think that made a difference. Great job buddy!
Looks a lot better. I agree I don't think lines are needed. Looks good on brown. :)
Fun and cute! Maybe add some highlights or shading to toaster but even if not, still good to go! Love it.
Great concept. I would buy it as is. Simple yet energetic.
add shading and good to go
Thanks for your feedback on my design. I think yours is great the way it is, nice job!
My design is up for scoring, if you get a chance take a look and leave a comment!
this design looks ready for submission!
i'd buy this shirt for my girlfriend.
hi it looks Cute & eye catching
i would suggest u can add some text or a single letter with some effect... like i dnt know could be Popup Toast!...or anything:)
& Guys... Plz also put ur valuable commnets on my design.. need ur help a lot! Angel Fallen.. thanks:)
very cute - would be perfect for my niece...
I agree with adding shine to the toaster and maybe reducing the size down just a tad.
I like the conceptual illustration of bread jumping out of the toaster for hot, cool
That perspective looks much better - looks finished to me :)
i think this is ready.. good job!
If you have time, please critique my design Giraffiti
id buy it
if you have time could you please critique mine
Thank you all for your usefull comments, I have decided to go for it with this version, wish me luck, and I would appretiate if you would score my T. Again thank you all very much
Here is the link where you can score th design
Sorry, the link is not ready yet, I will let you know