Get the skinny on new designs!
Forgot your password?
Not a member yet? Join us!
Score More Designs
Yay! You scored all of the submissions!!!
Grab the link
Embed Scoring Widget
Easy there killer. Ok, can I just take a moment and say that what passes for a critique on this site is really pretty lame. In the 11 comments left thus far, almost noone has managed to write anything approaching a well reasoned critique. No one has given me any useful criticism of the design, really, and no one has quite explained any of their feelings on it conceptually. The whole idea of a critiique IS to explain why you feel the way you do, otherwise it's practically useless to the artists. So, if you're gonna write something, please take the extra minute and a half to elaborate on what you mean. If you hate it, tell me why. If you love it, tell me why.
Also, for anyone who's not clear, this isn't supposed to be a serious shirt by any means. I'm not trying to promote emo or to bash it (ok, so it may contain a little friendly mockery). It's really entirely based around the idea that an emo-ish looking cherub would be kinda funny. So just cool your jets people.
Thanks very much. That was a very helpful crit and I'll definitely consider those suggestions.
callmeMooCow, I'm sorry that you seem to have taken offence to my "bitiching." I was not trying to chastise anyone inparticular. I was simply trying to point out that the comments section on this site is really not being taken adavantage of, to the detrement of everyone submitting t-shirts. And I guess it worked because after that post people have left much more interesting and helpful comments.
Of course everyone has the right to say what they want (as long as it's constructive and respectul, as the note below the Leave A Comment bar says) but I guess I just don't see the point of leaving a comment at all if you're not going to make some attempt to explain yourself. Why not simply vote and be done with it? And if everyone tries a little bit harder to give real crits, then everyone benefits. It doesn't really take that long and the people submitting get useful feedback while the people critting get practice at analyzing designs (analyzing someone else's work tends to help you judge your own a little better too).
That said, I'd like to thank everyone who did take the time to leave more elaborate comments (keep doing it with every design you crit!) and, again, I didn't mean to offend anyone so I'm sorry if I did.