poop paper scissors?

yeah, loose the werdz. It is cool concept though.
maybe differnt colors...

poor execution im afraid

more iconic err icons would be better, those ones are a bit shite frankly. sorry but its true. and maybe lose the text too.

Good idea. Poor execution. Here's how I see it:

Have a peice of paper with a cut in it
on top of a rock
which has smashed a pair of scissors

I'm not skilled enough to draw that, though, so if anyone uses what I just described, I get half of the money. =P

the rock isn't working man

No offense, but the rock really looks like poop. Literally.

Its a cool idea, I guess, but it needs some work. The consistency is all wrong. The 1st one is solid, while the other two are outlines only. The second two are just Wing Ding Characters. So, the consensus is, the two you didn't create look nice, while the rock, which Im assuming you did, is off the mark. Find a better symbol for the rock and have it match the other two, or hand draw and fill in a picture of paper and scissors

and maybe shoot for a "grey" rock

yeah...so? Rock, paper, scissors. OK. Now what?

you guys are freaking lame. give the guy a break you assholes.

Brett, we're not here to be cheerleaders. We're offering up constructive criticism. If the design isn't up to par, who are we to pad his ego rather than help him make the design better.

most of the comments seem pretty constructive to me.

change the colors. the brown makes the rock look like poo.

androidmice's suggestion is definitely pretty neat.

i like the idea, maybe better graphics and more interaction like someone said. and yeah, different colored rock...like grey rock on different colored shirt. on black with silver/white graphics. nad unnecessary text.