There is nothing wrong with subbing this because it only has two things in common with the other printed design: cake and a title. That being said, i guess the joke here is that a bunch of little cake gnomes are putting the piece of cake together? This could get a ton more fun in the details, with gnomes all over the cake, passing each sprinkle up the ladder and possibly a gnome around the side with a welder's mask on, blowtorching the cake into place and etc.
^I like FA's idear of expanding on who's constructing this cake; I see a little fellow with one of those long trowel things for smoothing out concrete coming back off the ladder after smoothing the frosting...
I agree too with FA. It's cute nonetheless, but I think it'd be more awesome with the little gnomes all over the place. Right now, people would just be thinking "why do you have a cake on your shirt?" but with the additions, they'd be like öh, cute, the gnomes are making the cake. haha". But I give it a good score anyway because I like cake. :)
About my design