Scoring has ended
The stats
Scoring finished:
236 days ago
Submitted on:
Nov 26 '07
Scored by:
1,528 people
Comments:
13 comments
Final average score:
1.69 out of 5
Link to this design
Click to see some ultra-fancy banner options, ready for use on your blog!



PinkyMcCoversong
A combination of two of my childhood favorites: dragons and baking cookies, for a grand total of AWESOME.
JoeMonster
JoeMonster on Nov 26 '07
great for a kid's shirt!
thejosher
thejosher on Nov 26 '07
concept is cool but the drawing.. eh.. not so much.
b.ran
b.ran on Nov 26 '07
AWESOME idea, i love the concept--especially because it's based off of your own child hood. I think that the drawing could use some work though, at the moment it looks like something that could have been done in ms paint. I absolutely LOVE how happy the dragon looks though!
JanVic
JanVic on Nov 26 '07
make the girl slightly bigger, you can't tell that what she's holding are supposed to be cookies. (or unbaked cookies).
kjloveday
kjloveday on Nov 27 '07
Really cute concept, but the execution is weak. Take more time with your line work and it'll pay off big time.
Ariel132
Ariel132 on Nov 27 '07
i like the drawing style but i agree that the cookies could be more defined. i love the idea though
pylms
pylms on Nov 27 '07
I think it'd be funny if the girl's flesh were melting away but they were both still smiling. I don't know if that would make me more likely to buy it, but whatever. But yeah, the drawing could be better.
jonesp1090
jonesp1090 on Nov 27 '07
weak
2 days later
joshhupp
joshhupp on Nov 30 '07
I have to agree with everyone. I like the concept, and there's nothing wrong with using MS paint, but you have to take time to clean up the lines and work with it it more. I think this sub is premature. You should spend some time in the critiques. It takes a while to get some comments, but it's worth it. Here was one of my favorite critiques using MS Paint. Keep improving!
cityclass
cityclass on Nov 30 '07
i dont like the back; it's unnecessary.
PinkyMcCoversong
PinkyMcCoversong on Dec 01 '07
Thanks for all the feedback, guys! I didn't use paint, though! This was hand-drawn then edited in photoshop! It *is* meant to emulate a childlike drawing style. I guess it does take a while to get feedback in critiques - I went through several versions for about a week, but this has given me even more feedback. I will certainly be revising!
pluminanicebox
pluminanicebox on Dec 03 '07
I second the opinion that the back is unnecessary. Everything else is awesome.
You must be logged in to leave a comment.
Update: Jul 21, '08
Update: Steve Wierth
Threadspotting every Friday!
You know they'll love it!
© 2008, a skinnyCorp LLC company. All designs Copyright by owner.    Privacy Policy.    Terms of Use.      Weekly new tees      In stock      News      Submissions      Thriftee