 |
|
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
 |
nice job, not so keen on the placement to be honest, i'd like it a little smaller, but top marks,,,
|
 |
i like the layout of it on the shirt, any smaller and i think it would be mistaken for just a heart
$ |
 |
Wow. This is one of the few hearts I would wear. I have to listen to the record now to get the song out of my head. $5
|
|
id like it more if the design was over the entire shirt instead of the heart shape, but maybe that's just me. the bottom is fine but the top kind of bothers me. i like the overall idea though
|
|
I love that exactly as it is. Really subtle and unusual. Any smaller and it would totally detract from the effect
|
 |
so cool!!
|
 |
NICE! $5
|
 |
shake your ass, tell me what your working with
|
 |
love the name, love the design. Beautiful work. I'd like to see it a bit smaller as well - I don't think we'd miss the girl. 5
|
 |
I prefer it the way it is now. Id buy $5
|
 |
love everything about it - only thing is that i wouldn't wear it 'cause of the nipple - it is beautiful, though
5 |
 |
That's insane! 5!
|
 |
Yep, Very cool. I like it BIG.... $5
|
 |
pritty cool
|
 |
MUST HAVE! $5!
|
 |
I remember my mom singing "Norwegian Wood" when I was little...I had NO idea what it was about, but it's a pretty song...
I am loving this shirt. I'd definitely buy it for a guy friend of mine who would love it. :D |
 |
Smitty! Awesome work! It's been forever since I've seen your stuff.
|
 |
And when I awoke I was alone
This bird had flown So I lit a fire Isn't it good Norwegian wood? can i just say: 1) i love the beatles (b) especially this song by the beatles 2)i'm norwegian 3)i love this shirt design 4)i say, keep it BIG! |
|
smaller on the shirt so you can see the whole heart might look nicer,
|
 |
Amazing! i want to wear this right now!
|
|
Very nice. Well rendered, true to the song.
|
|
In person, I hope the design is more readily identifiable. That said, I think the design is beautiful. All those lines that comprise the woman's hair is supposed to be a fanciful take on the rings of a tree, right? This is awesome.
|
 |
it looks great huge. nahice job yase!
|
 |
fo sho!
|
 |
kinda nice, but the question is: where have we seen that lady in that pose before..
|
 |
Maybe the lady should be like.. Any other color than brown? hate brown :(
Otherwise super design.. |
 |
You have cool design ! -
Please view my works ! http://www.threadless.com/profile/618580/Kirill_Best_2008/ |
 |
its super!
keep it in brown, I like it. isnt that what colour wood is anyway? |
|
I think smaller would be better. Although bigger seems to give it a bit of a tie dye effect. Torn.
But neato! |
 |
reminds me of Mucha
i love it 5$ |
 |
Pretty! I like that it's a heart but not a big obvious heart :P I would buy this...especially since I have been obsessed with this song lately o_O 5!
|
|
Ah.. thanks Yrie: http://students.ou.edu/W/Nicholas.J.Wojcik-1/mucha.jpg
I'm sorry, I don't think tracing a quite well-known artwork by a famous artist is a good idea :/ |
|
Damn good...I love the size of the heart and the way it spills onto the sleeves. 5$
|
|
thanks winkelmander, now I'll score low instead...
|
|
eh. not good.
|
 |
I'm sorry, I don't think tracing a quite well-known artwork by a famous artist is a good idea :/
ugh... such a fucking shame. though an interesting take - 0. |
|
I'm surprised nobody saw it before me.
|
 |
I like the obvious Mucha reference.
|
|
I adore this shirt, the title seals the deal completely... Probably because I'm a Beatles fanatic... If this is not printed, then my life will be incomplete. Everything about it is perfect. I love the colors as well.
I really hope this gets printed. $5 all the way. And as far as the "tracing" issue is concerned, it's not exactly the same. And what's wrong with doing it as an ode to the artist? As long as the person acknowledges where they got the idea from, then I have no problem with it. I mean, look at all of the Rene Magritte inspired stuff that comes up on this site, that's just one example anyway... |
|
I have no problem with famous artworks inspiring people, but I'm a bit disappointed that someone actually traces something instead of making his own version of the figure. Then it doesn't matter if he made her naked and drew a heart around it, to make a 'new' image.
But because the girl is traced, Threadless probably can't legally print this due to image rights. Well, and yeah, he should've at least said he was 'inspired' by Mucha. Because now it's like he is presenting the image of the girl like it's his own creation. (well, blahblah, I don't want to make a big thing out of this and debate it endlessly. I just think it was a bit lame and not too smart, especially after the whole Todd Goldman episode a while ago..) |
 |
i like! 5
|
|
Very cool design-I wouldn't wear it though. 5
|
|
nice, good song too
|
 |
i like the concept and i love the Beatles but i don't wear naked girls on shirts
|
 |
FRICKINAWESOME on Nov 11 '07 Great concept and design, i just wish her arse was a bit thicker instead of straight down.
|
 |
Bramish on Nov 11 '07 I'd much prefer this without the girl.
I wouldn't say tracing only the outline of the girl from another painting and then using it in a completely different design was stealing, but you maybe should have pointed out where you got the figure shape from. |
|
Yeah I don't know if I would call it stealing either. Like I said I'm not saying all this to start a witch-hunt or anything.
But then again, if he would've traced part of someone elses design here on threadless, people would probably be upset and call it stealing. And that's not any different from tracing Mucha I guess, but somehow it seems worse. Huh?! ;) |
|
Bramish on Nov 11 '07 Very true
|
|
cool design !
|
 |
i'd buy this! nice work
PLEASE PRINT!!! |
|
*sigh* Liked it for about 5 seconds, before I recognized it as a crude tracing of Mucha's "Dance."
|
 |
Nice artwork!
|
 |
nice artwork. Especially the hair make the whole thing awesome.
|
 |
Jemae on Nov 12 '07 PERFECTee! five! :)
|
|
i like the design, but i dont like the way it takes up the whole front of the shirts. i would buy it if it was smallers, in the middle of the shirt.
|
|
its actually not a trace, here is another example of the same pose. Geez, I didn't know you could copyright a pose people
http://www.bmasse.com/Images/Dylan_Simon_fxd.jpg |
|
I'll go ahead and argue this one:
http://www.bmasse.com/Images/Dylan_Simon_fxd.jpg is quite obviously a plagiarized version of http://students.ou.edu/W/Nicholas.J.Wojcik-1/mucha.jpg. Then you plagiarized it, as well. Two wrongs do not make a right, my friend. If you would have taken this pose from an anatomy textbook, that's another story, but you borrowed material from someone else and didn't cite it. Threadless is most likely tired of dealing with cease and desist letters... Trust me, this will not be a print. |
|
well, if it is too close of an image to both Masse and Mucha then I apologize. I had no intention of making this a copy and although I still don't believe that it is I understand the community's point and ask that if you are disturbed or upset by this image simply vote low for it. I was not trying to pull the wool over any ones eyes and claim stolen art as my own. I just wish there had not been such a problem with this in the past, now the entire Threadless community gets up in arms over everything.
|
|
its actually not a trace
no? I beg to differ: |
|
(sorry html mistake)
I meant: |
|
argh!
I'll just give the link: http://i12.photobucket.com/albums/a226/winkelmander/muchatrace.jpg |
|
I was not trying to pull the wool over any ones eyes and claim stolen art as my own.
I know, I know.. you did try and make a new image out of it. Maybe you didn't know that you cannot commercialy use someone elses image (yes, even if traced I believe. I think it would've been ok-ish if you just drew an image after Muchas work. But photoshop says you traced, sorry!) And if you didn't know all that, well, everybody makes mistakes and now you know this would be considered plagiarism. And hopefully not do it again. |
 |
It really is very attractive, and I love the concept. I do wish you had drawn it yourself, though.
|
 |
yeah amazing!5
|
|
It is beautiful. I have to add to the voices calling for smaller. I'd like to see the whole heart on the front of the shirt.
|
 |
i vote to keep it large.
my two cents on the plagiarism issue: you can't copyright a chord progression, and you can't copyright a pose. fine by me. |
|
while the tshirt itself is beautiful, it's disappointing that the work is plagiarised rather than appropriated. Sorry!
|
|
The design is good, but did not note on the T-shirt, you should change the color or design of the shirt
|
 |
I was gonna argue this one too. But that pose (and it is a ripe off of mucha) is a much used clip art as well. A lot of mucha's stuff got filtered into clip art. I think that the originality of the placement is marred by the use of such a well known pose and image. Re work it a bit and bring it back.
|
|
people... just because one person got away with stealing another person's design (clip art... what have you...) doesn't mean it's OK. original ideas work best.
rework it, and i can dig. the original portions of this design are my favorite parts, really (the wood, biiig print utilizing belt-print techniques). |
|
Dear everyone:
I will definitely rework it and resubmit it, I am already playing around with it. Thanks for your comments so far. |
|
Good idea, it could be a great tee :)
|
 |
Well I loved it anyway. Great placement especially.
|
 |
awesomeness
i would buy it just like that! no changes |
 |
Sweet placement!
|
 |
The title sold it for me.
|
© 2009, a skinnyCorp LLC company. All designs copyright by owner.
