Defeat
Scoring has ended
The stats
Scoring finished:
1814 days ago
Submitted on:
Jun 08 '07
Comments:
43 comments
Average score:
2.33 from 2,333 votes
Share with friends
My other submissions
 |
wow this is funny. concept is very threadless-esque. what's with the blue swirly thing on the right side of the dog, though? is that his tail?
|
 |
I like the concept but I am bothered by the blue swirl and the way his back is shaped. I have never seen a dog with such an arch in their back, it looks very unnatural
|
 |
Funny!
|
|
Nice and stylized. Not everything has to be naturalistic! $5
|
 |
The dog doesn't look right to me, adore the concept though
|
 |
I love this but I'm sorry it looks like your St. Bernard is struggling to take a dump and that is just not something I want to wear around :-(
|
 |
ditto what katfriend said
|
 |
Despite other comments, I love the shape of the dog. You could lose the blue tail though.
|
 |
yep, lose the blue tail. otherwiser i love it
|
 |
fix the tail
|
 |
jillustration on Jun 08 '07 i like.
|
 |
The tail looks very weird - why not just draw it with the color of the fur instead of having it look like some strange hole in the back?
|
 |
I don't like the tail..but I love that he's so arched and unreal looking..it makes him charming. :)
|
 |
the tail and the blue on the nose are weird, but other than that it's cute:D i'd wear it
|
 |
i really appologize about the tail everyone
|
|
ill fix it.
|
 |
i didn't get the saint bernard thing until after you explain it. i don't think the shirt would read too well out in public.
|
|
this is so cute, i would totally buy it!
|
|
not on blue... O_o
|
 |
Aw, look at his face. So sweet. I love this except for the blue tail. And I think just about everybody can tell it's a St Bernard, I mean seriously, who else wears a little brandy keg on their collar?
The funny shape of his back helps convey the size, I think. I'm a sucker for a good dog sub. Perfection. |
 |
So cute ! $5
|
 |
i love the big dog
|
|
I wouldn't wear it, but i love the symbolism. A bit sad tho :-(
|
 |
I love the size. It's so animated and charming. how else are you supposed to fit a big dog on a shirt? Don't worry about proportions either. Wile Coyote and Road Runner are nothing near their actual representations. I do however think the background is lacking something (like maybe a window or wall paneling). I like this but not enough to buy.
|
 |
FRICKINAWESOME on Jun 10 '07 Why is there a St. Bernard-shaped bear on this tee? The concept is pretty good, but the wierdly misshapen dog kinda kills it for me. Nice drawing skillz tho.
|
 |
oh so cute :) i'd buy, awee. Original too ..
|
 |
Skipper6745 on Jun 10 '07 Absolutely perfect. Emotional, funny, perfectly executed.
5$ |
 |
very cute!
|
 |
This is very sweet, and I like the idea. You captured the St Bernard's face and expression really well. But the body is just too weird looking. I know you're probably going for stylization, but it just looked warped.
Make the St Bernard more... St Bernard shaped, and this is spot on. |
 |
love the idea, but agree with the comments about back being too arched (makes it just look wrong somehow) and the tail
|
|
he needs hairclips for his eyelids.
|
 |
Why the heck does everyone want a less cartoony dog? The whole gag relies on his sullenness and the exaggerated pose makes that perfect. I like it like it is, and the tail is also fine. Nit pickers. 5
|
|
I don't want it less cartoony. The back just looks weird and detracts from the rest of the image. It's like there's some kind of joke in the size of his back (like, is he supposed to look like a mountain), but there isn't.
|
 |
i love it.
|
 |
it's sooo sweet! i like it a lot!
|
 |
hauhauhuahua! 5$
|
 |
Cuuute!
|
 |
i agree about the tail [saw that you were fixing it too just wanted to add in]. its sweet though it shoud def go on kids shirts if it gets printed. the blue doesnt look wintry enough though.
|
|
Why does he look like the hunchback version of a st. bernard? Umm... maybe if it actually looked like a st. bernard - but not like this.
|
|
Don't mind the naysayers! I love the hunched-up look of the dog. He just looks SO sad! Like he'd make himself tiny if he could. The blue tail is a bit weird, but otherwise, I love the concept. The only reason I wouldn't wear it is because I look horrible in blue :(
|
 |
good about the fixing, is the dog's back supposed to look a little like a mountain or is it just me? very lovely design though.
|
 |
I love the look of the dog too. Don't change it.
|
 |
People.. don't bash the art style.
It's art. I love it.. it's amazing. Well done. :) |
You must be logged in to leave a comment.
About my design