I like the old one better. the contrast is...odd. it lacks distinction. I think that the colors are also not particularly complimentary to the shirt or each other.
Awesome, I'm so glad you tried another version of this. I like this one a lot better. I think a large design would only look appropriate on a large person :) No offense to large people. But yea, I like this a lot better. Colors are just as strong in my opinion, I would go with either.
Kudos for taking constructive criticism. Mine was one of the suggestions to go monochromatic with the shirt color. I think the only thing wrong with this one is the way the sample came out. The detail in the other was better, so I know it's just the sample file. thumbs Up!
About my design