Threadless.com - Best t-shirts in the world
Type Tees - Amazing tees created from submitted slogans!
The Select Series - Artist edition limited invite only tee shirt designs
Threadless Kids - Designer kids & baby clothing
batbanana
batbanana aka Jenine is a 25.28 year old girl, has been a member since January 29, 2005, has scored 9392 submissions, giving an average score of 1.00.
  Jun 14 '05 by batbanana        10 Comments        Watch this      Share:  Share on facebook    Share on delicious    Share on digg    Share on MySpace    Tweet this    Stumble this    Share this on Kaboodle   
i hate to do this, but i'm in need of some feedback.
lookit that picture there, to the left. yep. that one. what do you think? it got a pretty good score, but I didn't get any helpful comments, just "ooo i like it" x's 21.

so yes. be hard and thorough.

or if you work for threadless... put in a good word for me. mama needs some bread to buy some dough to feed her 14 hungry kiddies.

travis76
   travis76 on Jun 14 '05 at 12:18pm
like me, it looks like your style has evolved to fit the threadless taste a little more than the earlier work...(not that our outside work has changed, of course)
my honest critique: drop the window. it's not drawn as well/bold as the rest.
i'm finding less is more lately..the bird and phone are busy and important enough on their own. as much as the darkest blue/grey is a good third color, it kinda flattens everything. you think it would make the yellow pop, right?
Pifman
Pifman on Jun 14 '05 at 12:22pm
Well at first I thought the bird was saying profanities (swearing) into the phone. Then I realized that it was coming from the phone. Then I realized that it was music stuff and not your average cartoon *$#!@! So I guess I'd move the music note (that the bird is saying) to the left side. And make it a little more clearer that the top part is coming from the phone (maybe lengthen the lightning bolt thing that goes to the phone?). Also, is he pissed? That's what his eyebrow tells me. But if he was pissed you'd think there'd be a ! after the music note. Otherwise I like the style.
Robotron5
Robotron5 on Jun 14 '05 at 12:23pm
I agree with Travis, also i would keep away from the brown shirt on the submission as it makes the other colours seem somewhat harsh in comparison.
travis76
   travis76 on Jun 14 '05 at 12:24pm
oh, i didn't even look at the sub page, i just looked at the profile pic. but i agree.
batbanana
batbanana on Jun 14 '05 at 3:37pm
mmm ya, the brown shirt looked great, until i put it beside the beautiful subdued colours of the blue vers.

I think i'll probably redo everything from scratch except for the main focus - the bird and the phone.

thanks dudes for your thoughts!

I'll probably be resubmitting vers. 2 in a week.
batbanana
batbanana on Jun 14 '05 at 7:42pm
i lied. the new version is coming as soon as they put up the next batch. IF they let it go through. typically resubmissions are frowned upon, so i hope the threadless stafferoo decide to be nice.

ALSO. I got a job. that's right. a REAL job.
at black's photography. should be a-ok.

so after tomorrow, i am a full time working gal.
RaeKuusou
RaeKuusou on Jun 14 '05 at 7:54pm
i actually really like the window in the background....it makes it more of a scene instead of just the bird character.

i would just make it more clear that the song note is comign from the bird, and the swears are comign from the phone.

;)
HarvestMoon
HarvestMoon on Jun 14 '05 at 8:02pm
I'd actually just like a happy or confused bird asking into the telephone and no one on the other line. I too, like the window, tis good.
pseudonymjones
   pseudonymjones on Jun 14 '05 at 8:09pm
I've been looking at this design for a few days now and I just noticed that it's the person on the phone swearing and not the bird. I am painfully unobservant.

I am not so fond of the window as it is now, but I do like the scene it creates. Perhaps it deserves a redraw or maybe you could use a lighter color for the lines to make the bird and phone stand out more against it. I only count three colors, maybe use one more for the sake of a subtle background?
batbanana
batbanana on Jun 14 '05 at 10:35pm
in the remake i got rid of the background. it looks better, as travis so astutely presumed.
You must be logged in to leave a comment.
My gallery photos

My designs

All about me
I'm a painting student in Canada somewhere.
That's probably all you need to know.

...that, and I love PONIES.