MS Paint and Clipart are bad swear words. Don't say them/don't type them. Don't let me see them in your designs. Do your own work even if it is just a complete retracing. LiveTrace is ugly also.


How I Grade:
5: Total awesomeness + I'd definitely buy
4: Awesome + I'd buy
3: Good Concept + Good Art (might buy)
2: Ok Concept + Ok Art (probably won't buy)
1: Effort
0: Plagiarized/Looks like a 3 second job in MS Paint

I don't care how good it looks, anything repulsive automatically gets a low score
Grading low due to personal opinions, tastes, and such is stupid. I view things with an artist's eye.