I got limewire up and running, so I will listen (or try) to any suggestions now.
Oh baby!

Anything that sounds like:

Arcade Fire
Badly Drawn Boy
Belle&Sebastian
Belltower
Blind Melon
Bright Eyes
Castanets
Cursive (Pre-Happy Hollow)
The Decemberists
The Faint
The Fiery Furnaces
The Flaming Lips
Half-Handed Cloud
Jenny Lewis & the Watson Twins
Kind of Like Spitting
My Brightest Diamond
Neutral Milk Hotel
Now It's Overhead
Pavement
Postal Service
Radiohead
Rafter
Regina Spektor
Rilo Kilry
Shapes&Sizes
The Smiths
Son, Ambulance
Spoon
The Stars
Sufjan Stevens
Supertramp
Tilly & The Wall
The Unicorns
Wilco
Yo La Tengo.

:D thankz!