I got mine and I am sad to say it does not fit at all. The material is scratchy and rough and has no give, unlike my other AA shirts. In fact, it feels like FOTL, which is to say: nasty. It's also cut about an inch or two narrower (It's definitely AA, though. The stubby little taglet is evidence of that.)

Between the smaller size, the large print area with no give, and the non-stretchiness, there's really no hope of this shirt fitting me, and unfortunately I got a girly XL so I can't just send it back for the next size up.

Now to the question: for anyone else with this shirt, is it the same as mine, or did I get a wonky one? I know there are misprints here and there, and this could be an L, but I fear it's not and the different material and poor quality control are at fault.

Basically I'm trying to decide whether to send it back for credit or send it back for another girly XL. Thoughts?