Threadless

JeF
JeF aka Jef is a 30 year old boy, has been a member since July 23, 2001, has scored 29,031 submissions, giving an average score of 1.78, helping 145 designs get printed.
First of all if you don't think video games count as art you can GTFO right now. This blog is for the video game nerds out there.

So the Smithsonian is having people vote for which games should be included in their video game exhibit coming up.

You can vote here: http://www.artofvideogames.org/

You can vote by era, console, and genre and I'm telling you some of these choices are almost impossible.

I thought I'd throw out some of the ones that I'm having difficultly deciding on and see if we can get some lively debate on them.

Era 1:
I'll admit I'm not too familiar with a lot of these although Space Invaders vs. Missile Command vs. Yars Revenge gave me some difficulty. I ultimately went with Space invaders.

Era 2:
I sadly never had a Commodore 64 or a Sega Master System, but when it comes to the NES they threw me for a loop.

Mega Man 2 vs. Super Mario Bros. 3 vs. Metroid - Holy Crap! How the heck do you decide between these three? I went with Mega Man 2.

Final Fantasy vs. The Legend of Zelda!! - I had to go with Zelda but it tore my heart out to do so.

Era 3:
Sega Genesis - I was a little disappointed by the choices they made for this system.

SuperNES:
Super Mario World vs. Donkey Kong Country was a pretty hard choice, but I went with Super Mario World.

Chrono Trigger vs. Zelda ALTtP vs. Earthbound was another one that I found almost impossible to decide on. Winner: Chrono Trigger.

Era 4:
Windows/Dos
The only one that really gave me trouble here was Starcraft vs. Command and Conquer, but I spent far more time playing C&C so I had to vote for it.

Nintendo 64
Zelda Ocarina of Time vs Zelda Majora Mask, is there even a question here? This was a total gimme.
Same with Golden Eye 007 this was a hands down winner.

Sega Dreamcast - haha! The only reason I recognize any of the games for this system was because I worked at a video game store when this system was released.

PS1 - I would vote for FFVII over any game in any system for all time.

Era 5:
I'll be honest, I'm more of an old school video game guy so some of these new fangled games I don't like as much, but here are a few I do:

Xbox 360: Bioshock
Windows: Portal (love it), Fallout 3
Wii: Zelda Twilight Princess
PS2: God of War vs. Shadow of the Colossus was a tough choice, I went with Shadow of the Colossus since it was suppose to be based on artistic merit.

Final Fantasy X vs Kingdom Heart II vs Okami was another one I had to think about. I went with FFX because it's one of my favorite FFs

PS3:
Dragon Age Origins vs. Final Fantasy VIII, FFVIII was so disappointing to me I had to go with Dragon Age Origins.


Yeah, so those are some of my choices and I barely scratched the surface.

Do you agree/disagree with me? What are some of the choices that gave you difficulty? Are there any other games you thin should have been in the running but weren't?

Discuss!


JeF
JeF on Feb 23 '11 at 3:14pm
jeffreyg
jeffreyg on Feb 23 '11 at 3:16pm
PS1 - I would vote for FFVII over any game in any system for all time.

this.
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:17pm
MegaMan 2 over Mario 3?! You're mad!
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:25pm
Mario 64 vs Banjo Kazooie vs Shadows of the Empire?!

DON'T MAKE ME CHOOOOOOOOSE! :-(
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:27pm
there is no reason for Oddworld to be listed under Action genre. i love that game, but in no way is it an action game. it's more a puzzle/adventure game.
Ste7en
   Ste7en on Feb 23 '11 at 3:29pm
Mega Man 2 is artistically superior to mario 3, but its impact on gaming is much less significant...I havent gone to the site, but do they explain the purpose of the exhibit?
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:29pm
I think based on artistic merit, Mario 3 would beat Mega Man 2, but I'd vote Mario 2 over both of them.
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:31pm
Again, Portal is not an action game. It's a puzzle game. Their categorization is weird.
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:31pm
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:29pm
I think based on artistic merit, Mario 3 would beat Mega Man 2, but I'd vote Mario 2 over both of them.


you're...you're kidding, right?

right?

:-\
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:34pm
Based on artistic merit, yeah. I'd rather play Mario 3 than 2, though.
JeF
JeF on Feb 23 '11 at 3:35pm
but do they explain the purpose of the exhibit?
Yeah.

"Remember, this is an art exhibition, so be sure to vote for games that you think are visually spectacular or boast innovative design! "

JeF
JeF on Feb 23 '11 at 3:36pm
I think some games games that are missing based on those criteria are Mortal Kombat and Resident Evil.
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:36pm
but mario 2 is nothing more than doki doki panic with mario characters swapped in! it's the red-headed step-child of the mario franchise.
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:37pm
i think i went against the rules. i didn't vote based on visuals alone. i think that's a poor way to assess video games.

damn the man.
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:37pm
Western audiences don't know that! Don't tell them!
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:38pm
half-life 2 might visually superior to portal, but i'd choose portal any day.
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:41pm
Braid should've been on there somewhere. that game is gorgeous.
Ste7en
   Ste7en on Feb 23 '11 at 3:44pm
tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:36pm
but mario 2 is nothing more than doki doki panic with mario characters swapped in! it's the red-headed step-child of the mario franchise.


That has nothing to do with artistic merit. It would be like saying the score to Inception was not amazing because it was based on that french song.
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:46pm
as i said, i voted based on more than visuals. though i still prefer mario 3's visuals over mario 2's.
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:48pm
Voting Limbo over Mass Effect 2 was pretty fun.
Ste7en
   Ste7en on Feb 23 '11 at 3:48pm
Mario 3 had a great visual engine for its time and some cool art direction but it was less than cohesive, and some of the worlds aren't even worth playing...most people skip them with warps (even if they arent speed running)
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:50pm
based on visuals alone, i should've voted banjo-kazooie over mario 64. damn.
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:52pm
That's what's bugging me, though, this artistic merit thing. I can't look through all these games and tell myself that art was what the developers were going for. I feel if they don't have any real curators, a lot of these games will show up in the museum because a majority of people liked it.
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:53pm
liked them*
tracerbullet
   tracerbullet on Feb 23 '11 at 3:53pm
and a lot of n64 games suffered from crappy visuals, but they're still amazing games
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 3:57pm
Tony Hawk's Underground 2 wtf
deep space monkey
   deep space monkey on Feb 23 '11 at 4:10pm
WTF? I was expecting to have to choose between mortal kombat & street fighter 2, but neither of those were even there???

infact, no "fighting" games at all...
reags
   reags on Feb 23 '11 at 4:12pm
Eh pretty lame PS3 choices - where's MGS4, or any MGS over PS1/PS2 even?
mike bautista
mike bautista on Feb 23 '11 at 4:26pm
MGS 1 and 2 were in there. I don't understand why they chose 2 over 3, though.
taz-pie
taz-pie on Feb 24 '11 at 12:47am
mario 4lyfe
thedeetzes
   thedeetzes on Feb 24 '11 at 1:49am
My parents got me a dreamcast when I was like 11 or 12 and were super disappointed with my reaction Christmas morning. What were they thinking!!! I was so bummed/furious!
You must be logged in to leave a comment.

My gallery photos

I haven't submitted any photos. I guess I don't want free money.

All about me

I work for SkinnyCorp, so I'm cooler than you.

email: jefk@threadless.com

conquerclub

dinorpg

die2nite

The Hell-Raising Eyeless Angels of Death Official Clubhouse

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket



XBox 360 tag: Mega-JeF