Threadless

EddieA
EddieA aka Eddie Adolf is a 27.49 year old boy, has been a member since April 24, 2005, has scored 557 submissions, giving an average score of 1.28, helping 5 designs get printed.
"Hello Eddie Adolf,

Regarding: 'Over Looking Things...'

Unfortunately your submission was declined.

------------------------------------------------

The reason your design was declined is: too similar to original submission"

,,,OMG!!! The freaking reason its too similar to original submission is because it was a freaking redesign of the old one! AHH.

Drives me freaking crazy. Heres the 2 side by side. The one i did first is on the left. The newest that i was to submit is on the right. http://www.eddieadolf.com/gr.gif

the first one was them looking right at the trees going "wow the last 2 trees" now they're going "wow nice city, what trees?"

indieflea
indieflea on Jul 07 '05 at 9:30am
huh, yeah.. looks pretty different to me. oh well.
bortwein
   bortwein on Jul 07 '05 at 9:33am
honestly, I see what you did to change it, but the original is better.
zechmann
zechmann on Jul 07 '05 at 9:34am
i like the second one a lot better... even though the first isn't bad
icki
icki on Jul 07 '05 at 9:40am
the first one is defintely better, but it's not very good either. i think threadless was trying to tell u that in a nice way.
shimala
shimala on Jul 07 '05 at 9:42am
You made the trees taller and moved the cloud... by slightly changing your design a little bit based on comments, we still treat it as a duplicate. if the concept didn't go over well the first time around, just try something new...
mezo
   mezo on Jul 07 '05 at 9:44am
[insert OH SNAP! here]
Pifman
Pifman on Jul 07 '05 at 9:53am
Yeah if it makes you feel better man, I wouldn't know what the hell was going on in the second one if you didn't tell me. Not only is it ALL too dark, but it's way too abstract to understand some important message behind it.



But like Shimala said, they don't really love getting duplicates.
Skipper6745
   Skipper6745 on Jul 07 '05 at 11:25am
I don't think it looks very good. It's a bit too scribbly for my tastes.
EddieA
EddieA on Jul 07 '05 at 1:15pm
yeah, the first try was good, with a 2.94 just wanted to try something else with it
pinkerton
pinkerton on Jul 07 '05 at 1:20pm
Someone got told...
EddieA
EddieA on Jul 07 '05 at 1:20pm
psh, yeah i did.
bdragule
bdragule on Jul 07 '05 at 3:43pm
Question: what if the CONCEPT goes over really well, but the execution is crap? Then are resubmissions okay?
KatieTheMofo
KatieTheMofo on Jul 07 '05 at 3:44pm
I did a resubmission and mine went through.

Maybe they just didn't really like your design/concept much to begin with.
You must be logged in to leave a comment.

My gallery photos


My designs