Threadless

v1 I'm angry because you stole my cookies, 545 days ago, click to expand
v2 I'm angry because you stole my cookies, current version








Work in progress by:
The Results
Submit This!
1
Needs Work
2
Dont Submit!
4
Versions...
Version 1 - 545 days ago
Version 2 - 545 days ago

treyseah
treyseah on Nov 28 '10
Yup. New version's up. I wonder about that jar though. I need to portray it better I think.
treyseah
treyseah on Nov 28 '10
Any comments on improving it?
treyseah
treyseah on Nov 28 '10
Any comments on improving it?
Mr_Fingers
Mr_Fingers on Nov 29 '10
One thing that seems a little distracting to me is that the shirt color and the color of the character's face/cookie jar all start to blend into each other. I think a little more contrast in this design would help punch it up. Good stuff.
2gestalt
2gestalt on Nov 29 '10
Sorry, I don“t get the joke. And the guy looks a bit like from south park.

If you find the time, let me know your thoughts about my designs:
Dark side of the moon
Desperate Houses
Unsolvable Rubik

Nerdcat and Giraffic suicide are now up for scoring!
I appreciate if you score or comment on it!
fisticuffnyc
fisticuffnyc on Nov 29 '10
Yeah looks close to a south park character. Not a bad thing it's a great show. Not sure I get the joke either. As far as design the yellow cookie jar gets lost in the gray. Some shading and contrast should fix that.

Thoughts on mine would be appreciated.
http://www.threadless.com/critique/80621/Peace_Clown
treyseah
treyseah on Nov 29 '10
Haha thanks for the comments. Will work on the colour scheme and making the whole cookie thing more obvious

I guess it looks like the south park guys due to the style of art. I don't really watch south park though. Look forward to my next version!
debbilboy
debbilboy on Nov 29 '10
Most of my observations line up w/ the previous posters: too much like a South Park character, not enough colour contrast, idea not clear (not too sure what you can do about that, but my intitial reaction was "huh?"; then I read the title, and my reaction was still , "huh?"

I'd have a look at some tutorials on developing a character, like the ones at Smashing Magazine & Vector Tuts +, for inspiration, then start over.
Invisible Fox
Invisible Fox on Nov 29 '10
Like the others I don't get the joke either.
I like the first submission. Although the are no idea in it, it just at some point funny to have an angry man on your shirt. I would bye it.

Feel free to commit my design
http://www.threadless.com/critique/80124/Delivery
You must be logged in to leave a comment.