Threadless

v1 I Want to Be a Cowboy, current version








Work in progress by:
The Results
Submit This!
5
Needs Work
1
Dont Submit!
1

SlicedBread
SlicedBread on Aug 29 '07
This is (will be) my submission for the Iron and Wine
SlicedBread
SlicedBread on Aug 29 '07
Question: should I keep the skin a gray/red pattern or just use peach, since I have the extra color?
SlicedBread
SlicedBread on Aug 29 '07
?

SlicedBread
SlicedBread on Aug 29 '07
if no one has anything to say then i guess i'll submit it, but i'd really like some feedback
ibyes
   ibyes on Aug 29 '07
I was one of the 3 that said submit it. I like the concept the colors and the composistion. The color of the shirt is nice as well. Great job, although I think it would work even without the bubbles next to the kid. I like that the horse and the spaceship seem to be coercing the kid to decide, we don't need to see his thoughts (but that's just me) The way you have it works just fine as well.



can you critique

http://www.threadless.com/critique/7143/Musclestache



ibyes
   ibyes on Aug 29 '07
skin works fine for me as it is.
ejay
   ejay on Aug 30 '07
A slight adjustment to the pose (scratching his head with indecision , for example) will work if the bubbles are to be dropped , but I tend to like them, they fit in nicely. I do think that the hats are enough though , and the question/exclamation marks are not really needed- The indecision makes it more interesting than the choice, in my opinion.
SlicedBread
SlicedBread on Aug 30 '07
ejay, you have a good point, i wish i went with it that way, i did actually send this in to sub. the reason i stuck with my 'way' though was that i showed this to a few people before the speech bubbles were this clear, and they didn't understand it. not that i want everything to be spelled out, but i don't want too many people to think it doesn't make sense.
You must be logged in to leave a comment.