|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Nov 15 '08
My design is an island designed for reclining tv watchers.
|
|
jensbackvall on Nov 15 '08
Nice idea.
I'd like to see where you are going to place it. Please have a look at mine: http://www.threadless.com/critique/31233/How_to_Make_Faces |
|
S.O.S. on Nov 15 '08
It reminds me very much of that printed design that was the highest score ever, but was revealed to be stolen. The island is a fish and a man is fishing from the side of the island.
|
|
ahmedINchaos on Nov 15 '08
this is really cool, i love the concept and the illustration of it.
i think placement would be cool if its closer to the bottom, but still close to middle. |
|
Skilly on Nov 15 '08
Awesome, maybe the propellor could be tweaked a bit, it looks almost like Charlie Chaplin's legs sticking out the side, if you can see what I mean....and the bubbles could be more transparent, rather than totally filled-in?
|
|
OneBadMustache on Nov 15 '08
Cool design, I like it. I agree, the propeller might need a little tweaking.
|
|
genghis_g on May 04 '09
Any more comments, I decided to get back to doing this, and would like to see if there are any new thoughts.
|
|
Agent_Dick on May 04 '09
Mostly just tweaking for detail, sir. the prop, the tree needs highlights or leaver or something. I'd redo the dish. This is an awesome idea.
Send me a crit? http://www.threadless.com/critique/43227/Until_Cooler_Heads_Prevail |
|
RubyP on May 04 '09
Very cool idea. To me it would make a great T but judging from my ratings what do I know. I would buy it....
|
|
genghis_g on May 06 '09
Any other comments before I make alterations.
|
|
Bobzar77 on May 06 '09
maybe use the light green to fill in the left side of the tree trunk....
does it need a person? or is it an advertisement for this? |
|
wiladkins on May 06 '09
i agree that the propellors need more definition, have you tried it with an outboard motor on the back instead?
what do you think of mine? |
|
genghis_g on May 08 '09
bump
|
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on May 08 '09
Updated a few things. Mostly minor changes.
|
|
RubyP on May 08 '09
Still love it as it is. I'd buy it in a second. Just a really nice feel to the graphic and the colors as spot on. Now lets see it on a real T.
|
|
Grafica.cz on May 08 '09
|
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on May 08 '09
Ok then, is placement, color and size good?
I like the grey the best for the shirt. |
|
yellowpanda on May 08 '09
:D i like
|
|
Dani MA on May 08 '09
grey is good
like the idea http://www.threadless.com/critique/43548/Barcode ? |
|
RubyP on May 09 '09
I still like the light blue better T better but I'd still buy the T. Great design.
|
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Jun 24 '09
Design on blue tee.
|
|
Risdiansah on Jun 24 '09
haha cool... but i need to see more detail or activities on that island :).
Good work! a little help please for my designs :D http://www.threadless.com/critique/46993/Princess_and_the_Frog and http://www.threadless.com/critique/43381/Bully#v3 thx |
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Jun 24 '09
On Light Blue(which is different than V4's blue), Heather Grey(same as v3), and Sand.
I think these are the best colors for the shirt. Also, unless you guys give me a solid reason to add something, I'm prepared to keep the design like it is in V2 and these. |
|
JP_designer on Jun 24 '09
I think tat this actually works on all 3 shirt colours but i prefer the beige. You could try a dark blue and jsut change the water to a light blue. jsut a suggestion. but this is reallz fun.. oo waht about movig it up a bit on the shirt. I think this is pretty much ready for submission though. Well done A+
Could you vote for my design 1 Could you vote for my design 2 |
|
genghis_g on Jun 24 '09
I do like the beige(sand) shirt color the best. Should I just do the beige then. Or can I submit with three shirt colors.
|
|
nozm on Jun 24 '09
I like very much the idea and the style. to me it's nearly perfect.
and... oh my god... V1 is 220 days old... i think it's time to submit! comment mine |
|
genghis_g on Jun 24 '09
I actually started this design in like... 2007. I deleted that one and re-uploaded it for critique last Nov.
Should I just submit it like this though, or with the full Sand shirt, or maybe on somebody. |
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Jun 24 '09
Sand T-shirt.
Submit? |
|
harturo123 on Jun 24 '09
Yes. It looks better on sand. How about drawing a fat guy, with a beer in his hand sitting on the sofa?
Could you check out mine please? Thank you |
|
Skilly on Jun 25 '09
Looks good, but not sure about the second blue line on the right, it seems to confuse whether this should be viewed in profile, or more of a 3/4 view, if you know what I mean?
|
|
genghis_g on Jun 26 '09
Any other suggestions? I'll play around with adding a person.
The second line on the right is supposed to represent that the island is separating the water as it moves, and if that's too confusing for everyone, I'll consider changing it. |
|
Kim456 on Jun 26 '09
def change the second line and add a person
http://www.threadless.com/profile/955727/Kim456/blog/473661/I_like_blowing_bubbles |
|
Kim456 on Jun 26 '09
|
|
charity.ryan on Jun 26 '09
I love it! I think you've got a winner here. But I totally agree there should be a guy w/ a beer in the chair.
|
|
Simps0n on Jun 26 '09
GREAT ! SUBMIT!
|
|
mpeon on Jun 26 '09
woww, it looks great, ready to sub... what about a dude swiming at the back, trying to reach the island... and a coconut falling trying to defend the island, or something like that =P
can you please critique mine? emonalisa color zebra |
|
Ekspanzi on Jun 26 '09
kewl idea, i wud try with some fish and/or stars..
|
|
dleeson2 on Jun 26 '09
add the dude, remove the line.
does it look cool with a gold sun top left or right? |
|
bt_rule on Jun 26 '09
Cool idea!
As for that line, I would say remove it at the very least. If you're up for some more work make a bulge right behind the boat/island with a slope downward on the right side, then draw some more turbulent water behind the propeller... but you're probably going for the more relaxed look... Check mine out? Urban Piracy |
|
Ichi_Moore on Jun 26 '09
I'd make the placement higher. Cool idea though.
|
|
pmolick on Jun 26 '09
Very cool idea... I'd suggest removing the line and making the single remaining line rippled some, to show that it's moving.
I'm impartial about the guy at the moment, but would like to see how it looks... also think it would be good to show this on a real tee when it comes time to sub. |
|
Tigerbill on Jun 26 '09
Great idea. Looks good. Maybe just a little more contrast between the two greens. Also liked the fat guy in the chair idea.
It'd be great if you could critique the latest version of my design - Never mind the tigers... |
|
flifly flow on Jun 29 '09
wow, that's the island from my dreams, very nice!
|
|
Interesting idea. Tropical sunshine, tv and beer on a moving island. hahah. great
Mind if you critique my design for me please: Terra Micro |
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Dec 22 '09
Added the guy, and changed the water line.
I like the sand color for the shirt, but the tan color of the guy might make him hard to see. I could make him the same green as the island to match, but it might be hard to see him as well. Thoughts? |
|
DollGrin on Dec 22 '09
I think the guy should be the same tone as the chair, tv, and palm tree, so he pops out more.
|
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Dec 22 '09
Same as v7 but with green guy.
|
|
mblesse on Dec 22 '09
|
|
mblesse on Dec 22 '09
|
|
genghis_g on Dec 22 '09
Any other thoughts?
|
|
helldozer on Dec 22 '09
Hehe. Nice work. IMO, I'd like to see some different colors, or it applied to a few different colored shirts.
Any feedback is much appreciated: I Love the Rain Sad Clowns Are Funny |
|
genghis_g on Dec 22 '09
I have some different shirt color options in v5, but I liked the Sand color the best.
Does anyone else think the guy needs to be a different color. I do kind of like him as green, but I think yellow or red might work. I could try a few color schemes out and then post them all in one. |
|
Tony Flowers on Dec 22 '09
I like it. nice use of visual elements. Maybe it would be stronger if you could make out more of the person in the chair.
Fun |
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Dec 23 '09
Ok, some different color options for the guy.
Red, Yellow, White, Black, Green, Tan. |
|
Mobi on Dec 23 '09
I like the green version best, I think others stick out too much.
Style and idea are excellent, I'd keep it "2-coloured" and submit it :) If you have time, please check out my design. http://www.threadless.com/critique/58668/THE_Shadow . |
|
genghis_g on Dec 23 '09
I do like it with green.
Anyone else have thoughts? |
|
maestrostephent on Dec 23 '09
I like the red. Awesome design.
|
|
epocalypse on Dec 23 '09
go with green and it's ready to sub!
|
|
genghis_g on Dec 23 '09
Thanks so far, but I'd really like some more feedback.
I'm really leaning towards Green. |
|
Work in progress by:
|
|
genghis_g on Dec 23 '09
Ok. I've decided I want to have it with the Green. I think the guy blending in really works better overall for the composition. I like that it's simple with only the 4 colors, and it keeps the colors separate better wit hte guy blending in as well.
|
|
jrlandshark on Dec 23 '09
I really like it alot, i would vote it a 4. Submit!
would you check mine out? Gramophoning 101 - Jrlandshark |
|
BandB on Dec 23 '09
this is a great idea but it needs some definition. Maybe add some more contrast to the shades of green that you have on the top. the dark green looks too prominent and kinda blends in with the other green.
I also think you should make the little motor more prominent so that it's obvious, the bubble should also be larger. hope this helps, please vote on my slogans: http://www.threadless.com/profile/372949/BandB/slogans |
|
Abdulla Habib on Dec 23 '09
that's it... nice
see my critiques http://www.threadless.com/critique/58215/Space_creature http://www.threadless.com/critique/58496/Wounded_bird |


