|
I'm hoping to fine tune a lot of the design details so I'm looking for any feedback at this time.
|
|
Jennacat on Sep 05 '08
I think that's awesome as it is! I hope it gets printed! I don't know really if you need to fine tune anything, it looks good to me. I like it on the green especially.
http://www.threadless.com/critique/27846/Here_comes_trouble |
|
Mosquito88 on Sep 05 '08
I love how the two normal houses seem to have faces.
How about a grey-black&white color option? Can you score and comment my design? |
|
KDV on Sep 05 '08
Awesome design! Looks pretty good as it is. Maybe you could play a bit more with the other two houses and try to make it look like they are really looking at their strange neighbor. I don't know, maybe the middle house could exhibit some alien features as well? :)
I'd appreciate a look at my design too: Geek Chick |
|
heroben on Sep 05 '08
I like it.
http://www.threadless.com/critique/27752/I_Heart_Starfish |
|
davincheese on Sep 05 '08
love it!
maybe use a brighter colour to make it pop? http://www.threadless.com/critique/27843/Batman |
|
"I don't know, maybe the middle house could exhibit some alien features as well?" The fact that it has 3 window eyes and is on its side isn't enough. ;) Not sure what else I could add to the house part without over doing it. I'm thinking I need to make better tress and work on the background a bit.
|
|
Haha - nice. I like the muted tones, but I think it would be nice to see something popping. Perhaps the UFO in a futuristic silver foil if you could bear it?
|
|
yeah, I'm trying to figure out the best 8 colors to use to make this have the best contrast but still feel right. I like the idea of using a foil.
|
|
I might try to update this later tonight, so any more feedback could still make it into version 2.
|
|
Added some more details for the fun of it and changed the UFO to a Silver Foil like fatheed suggested.
|
|
Batnap on Sep 06 '08
Cool crop circles! Submit it.
|
|
AaronJH on Sep 06 '08
I like it on green...and yes, the crop circle on the lawn made me laugh. I agree... submit this.
drop on by and give me a crit: http://www.threadless.com/critique/27877/Internet_Prawn |
|
I'd like to improve the mountain behind it. Any suggestions?
|
|
notkin on Sep 06 '08
i think it would be better with no ufo. its not as obvious but i dont think it needs to be.
|
|
PuterBoy on Sep 06 '08
Make it a pointing mountain landscape.
like this: ^^^^^^^^ |
|
element_101 on Sep 06 '08
lol. this shirt makes me laugh.
|
|
that girl is cute who is she? :p
the greatest part of it is that the houses are looking at the one in the middle. nice man... do improve the mountain... |
|
bobuchan on Sep 06 '08
Cool concept and execution.
I like the ufo, but it is rather obvious. As cool as shiny foil is, maybe just a silhouette in the hill color? Your mountain probably just needs more little ridges. |
|
oh much improved. I dig it, and think it is ready to submit.
|
|
Ok, I feel like I improved the mountains. I made a Black and Grey option now shown on a guy model and I cleaned up a few things on the houses that were bugging me. I kept the foil because I really like how it works. How's it look?
|
|
oh and version 3 is the same as version 5 and version 4 was a glitch because I didn't think version 3 went through. So ignore those 2 versions.
|
|
marrgalo on Sep 07 '08
Mmmm when I looked your first version I really liked the UFO without the foil. I think it makes the shirt look a little tacky and that's definitely not the way I envision your design. It has a really cute, clever vibe! Just not feeling that tinfoil (on the green, mostly)
Please have a look at my design, it really needs some help: http://www.threadless.com/critique/27918/Reef_Safari Thank you! |
|
willypiva on Sep 07 '08
nice work!
the trees and the car on the right side could use some work |
|
no_skunk on Sep 07 '08
I just don't like the color for the spaceship...
|
|
good feed back. I'm going to work on the cars and trees now. I'm still torn by the use of the foil for the UFO, I kind of like it but I understand why it might be over the top for this design.
|
|
bobuchan on Sep 07 '08
Just keeps getting better ^-^
Maybe limit the foil on the UFO and/or add it to the houses too? Your mountain tops could use a little variation on the top of the white caps instead of the same line width. |
|
New cars, removed the foil from the green version but left it optional on the b lack option, and fixed a few other things.
|
|
iQuitt on Sep 08 '08
the green one is awesome... the black is boring... great design though...
|
|
KDV on Sep 08 '08
submit!
|
|
submit.
|
|
spacextoaster on Sep 08 '08
not eally a shirt i would buy, it's too plain for me...but it's really nicely illustrated, and smart. submittt.
need critique on mine too, if you have time to spare. http://www.threadless.com/critique/25832/gretel_likes_to_cut_and_paste |
|
Syncos on Sep 08 '08
Perfect as is. I'd wear it.
|
|
nice touch with the windows... sub it
|
|
VelociGent on Sep 08 '08
It's clean, but I think you could make it better. It could be a lot funnier than it is.
|
|
growabrain on Sep 08 '08
i think itd be better if the house was more like a trapdoor and less like a piece of lego on its side. i mean, i think its a great idea, its just that the house is kinda weird looking like that to me.
|
|
Some great touch's since the first crit. Love the window 'eyes' and the lawn/yard. Subiiiitt!
|
|
I think I'll submit this version. Thanks for all the help.
|
|
Submitted.
|


